10. Feist - The Reminder
Feist deserves the opening spot on this list for legitimizing indie music in the hearts, minds, and wallets of the mainstream listener. She was played relentlessly on the radio, seen in commercials for the ubiquitous ipod nano, and host of two incredibly entertaining videos on late night cable shows. This is all indicative of a great performer and character, and it almost overshadows the record itself, which is in every way a superior effort over Let It Die, both in terms of pop-infused singles, and intimate moments of introspection.
9. Bright Eyes - Cassadaga
Largely forgotten due to it’s February release and country tinge, Cassadaga is the furthest leap Conor Oberst has ever taken in his career, both in terms of musical definition and public image. 2007 was the year that Bright Eyes stopped being the poster boy of emo underground (though one could say that label was withering with the last pair of releases, Digital Ash/It’s Morning) and became something that few people saw coming: a full-fledged country music star. Cassadaga is the most listenable album in his collection, containing almost no misses. Critics claimed the record was too mainstream, too accessible, but Cassadaga is a pop country album, and these kinds of things should be accessible. On top of this, “I Must Belong Somewhere” is one of the best songs of the year, and the commissioned art video that accompanied it will bring hugs and tears to people who don’t even like the band.
8. Rilo Kiley - Under the Blacklight
Almost universally panned as being several steps backward, Under The Blacklight was another record swept under the rug this year. I planned on doing the same, except a strange thing happened: I couldn’t stop listening to it. It’s still the album I put on when I can’t find anything else. It’s become my go-to for reading, and it’s the de-facto soundtrack to my next book. It’s as good as any Fleetwood Mac wannabe band will ever get, and “15” is still one of my favorite guilty pleasures.
7. Kevin Drew - Broken Social Scene presents Spirit If…
I have no idea if Americans have even heard this album, but it doesn’t matter, as Spirit If… works just as well as an idea as it does a physical being. Basically, Kevin Drew put together most of the Broken Social Scene crew (which I believe consists of the entire population of Ontario. I might be on this record for all I know) but steered it in his own personal direction, which somehow warrants it as a solo record. Fine, whatever. It’s a Broken Social Scene record with a different name. It’s more or less a slightly less bombastic and better lyricized version of the BSS record from last year.
6. Animal Collective - Strawberry Jam
Animal Collective succeeded this year in doing the one thing that most bands simply cannot achieve: make a record so sonically complicated that it becomes nearly impossible to criticize while at the same time making it easy to listen to. Does that make it a great record by itself? Not in the least, but it turns out to be incredibly addictive anyway.
5. Bjork - Volta
Any year Bjork releases a record is one she appears on this list. Any year she releases a record full of actual songs that can be heard without a decoder ring, she ranks higher. Volta is a pressure cooker of a record, one that reveals itself full after repeat listens but doesn’t actually piss anybody off on the first go around, which actually might be a first for her.
4. Tegan & Sara - The Con
Another album filled with far more propulsion than its predecessor, The Con was Tegan & Sara’s heaviest record, and while maybe not as good all around as So Jealous, it definitely serves a better purpose. What The Con says about the band more than anything is that they have more venom in them than we knew, more fuel, and more drive to keep going after their hearts have been broken and their spirits split in twain. It’s a giant middle finger record that can be studied in various ways, but it’s also a straight ahead rock set from a band known for more optimistic fare.
3. Stars - In our Bedroom after the war
The last Canadian band on my list is the one I hold closest to me. For years now, Stars have been the cornerstone of my playlists. Rarely do I make a mix CD without one of their songs attached. In Our Bedroom After The War gave me thirteen new gifts to give to people I love. It’s a smaller sound than Stars’ last effort, but it’s meant to chronicle a feeling that’s smaller than lighting oneself on fire. It’s meant to display one’s feeling after the worst is over, even if there’s nothing left to hold onto. That’s a very difficult thesis for a pop band, but Stars pulls it off almost effortlessly.
2. MIA - Kala
Rolling Stone’s number 1 record of the year. I was a little surprised they didn’t give it to the Foo Fighters, but whatever. Kala has so many things going for it: A great origin story about MIA being rejected from the US due to passport issues, a censored video by MTV, a fantastic video done in Africa for Bird Flu, and a general sense that this album is going to change things for hip hop, pop, and rock music in the world. Perhaps it’s the threat of globalization looming over everyone’s head, but Kala was just so damn refreshing in so many ways. It made every other record that came near it sound like it was recorded two decades before.
1. Tullycraft - Every Scene Needs It’s Center
Sometimes, you’ll hear a song on the radio and it’ll stick in your head for weeks before looking it up. That’s what happened when I first heard “Pop songs your new boyfriend is too stupid to know about,” a song that isn’t on this record. Still, it made me look up Tullycraft. I’m really glad I did. Every Scene Needs It’s Center starts off with the most iconic song of the year in my opinion: “The Punks Are Writing Love Songs.” The entire album is a sarcastic response to the hipster posturing that ran rampant in 2007, all performed under the guise of candy pop. This sort of clever lyricism is a sadly missed art form. It’s a great record to do absolutely anything to, and it succeeds on every single level.